The quickest way to get your Bluetooth devices paired to your Raspberry Pi is through Terminal.

From the Raspberry Pi desktop, open a new Terminal window.

If you're pairing a keyboard, you will need to enter a six-digit string of numbers. You will see that the device has been paired, but it may not have connected. To connect the device, type connect XX:XX:XX:XX:XX:XX.

Now you can toss that ancient wired keyboard in the junk drawer of your desk until you reflash your Raspberry Pi tomorrow.